A.A. and Christian Science

Alcoholics Anonymous (A.A.), founded by Bill Wilson, has been in the spotlight this summer, as the organization celebrates its 75th anniversary.  An article by David Brooks, “Bill Wilson’s Gospel” (The New York Times, June 29, 2010), stood out for me, because of some surprising similarities between A.A. and Christian Science. I don’t mean to suggest the two are wholly alike, of course, but rather to use Mr. Brooks’ analysis of A.A. as a stepping-off point for sharing some facts about Christian Science, a system intended to meet all human needs.

Mr. Brooks describes the night when Bill Wilson, an alcoholic struggling in a New York City detox facility, cried out to God in desperation and felt God’s presence. “’It seemed to me, in the mind’s eye, that I was on a mountain and that a wind not of air but of spirit was blowing,’ [Wilson] testified later. ‘And then it burst upon me that I was a free man.’”

Mary Baker Eddy, the discoverer and founder of Christian Science, wrote, “Slavery is not the legitimate state of man. God made man free.” (Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures)

Wilson went on to found Alcoholics Anonymous, and Mr. Brooks uses A.A. as a springboard for examining what we can learn from it, not only about addiction, but, in his words, “about changing behavior more generally.” He enumerates some of the lessons gleaned from A.A.:

“In a culture that generally celebrates empowerment and self-esteem, A.A. begins with disempowerment. The goal is to get people to gain control over their lives, but it all begins with an act of surrender and an admission of weakness.”

This seeming contradiction — i.e., gaining control by surrendering — has a parallel in Christian Science, which involves letting go of the human ego and relinquishing a false sense of personal control by surrendering to the one Ego, God.

“In a culture that thinks of itself as individualistic, A.A. relies on fellowship. The general idea is that people aren’t really captains of their own ship. Successful members become deeply intertwined with one another — learning, sharing, suffering and mentoring one another. Individual repair is a social effort.”

This hearkens to church membership. Christian Scientists join in a worldwide movement, standing shoulder to shoulder with other Christian Scientists, taking a stand for spiritual healing — for salvation through the Christ in our understanding of one infinite, good God and as members of “His universal family, held in the gospel of Love.” (Science and Health) In our branch churches, we strive to learn from one another as we share our experiences of healing, thereby uplifting the community and “elevating the race” (Science and Health) as Mary Baker Eddy defined the spiritual sense of church demonstrated in human experience.

“In a world in which gurus try to carefully design and impose their ideas, Wilson surrendered control. He wrote down the famous steps and foundations, but A.A. allows each local group to form, adapt and innovate…. A.A. is decentralized, innovative and dynamic.”

Mary Baker Eddy specifically and repeatedly endeavored to turn all focus and attention away from herself, personally, alert to the pitfalls of human personality or celebrity. She defined The Mother Church as unique, with branches that operate democratically, giving local members both the responsibility and the privilege of working together harmoniously to keep their hearts and minds — and thereby their church doors — open to the world. I think it is fair to say that Christian Scientists aim for local Sunday Schools, Reading Rooms, and lectures that could be described as “decentralized, innovative and dynamic.”

Mr. Brooks concludes with this remarkable description of Wilson’s goal:

“But instead of addressing that problem [of addiction]…, Wilson set out to change people’s whole identities…. His group would help people achieve broad spiritual awakenings, and abstinence from alcohol would be a byproduct of that larger salvation.”

In answer to the question, “Is healing the sick the whole of Science?” Mary Baker Eddy replied, “Healing physical sickness is the smallest part of Christian Science…. The emphatic purpose of Christian Science is the healing of sin; …to save [mortals] from sin through Christ, spiritual Truth and Love, which redeem them, and become their Saviour, through the flesh, from the flesh, — the material world and evil.” (Rudimental Divine Science)

Mr. Brooks’ column is his response to the needs of his fellowman — those struggling to rise above addiction, illness, sorrow, financial difficulties, and relationship issues. As a Christian Science practitioner, I, too, yearn to help others claim their God-given right to freedom. The editors of The New York Times find this subject worthy of a column, because it suggests they recognize the crying need all around us and want to respond to it.

For 75 years, people in New York and elsewhere have turned to A.A. for answers and found relief from addiction — and maybe more. For over a century, New Yorkers and others have found relief from life’s challenges and improved lives through the system that Mary Baker Eddy founded — Christian Science.

This entry was posted in Christian Science, Healing, Health Care, Mary Baker Eddy, Prayer. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to A.A. and Christian Science

  1. Nancy Perry says:

    I am very moved by this vision of unity, or commonality, with the 12 step program. My spiritual journey really started with the 12 step program for an eating disorder that was untouched by any other treatment. Though I had been in an episcopal church regularly growing up, this was the first concrete step I took on a spiritual path. One thing the article referred to didn’t mention, that I was moved by after being in the program for years, and being healed of that disorder, and growing into life- is that the book (The Big Book) states the only way for sobriety to be maintained is through a deeper spiritual commitment beyond the 12 steps…. for me that became Christian Science, and it was seamless. I never wondered if it would have been better to just find Christian Science first, because those years, and meetings, and people, and courage, and service and love and trial, were all part of my cherished footsteps. It is the seamlessness that I am speaking to in replying here, because it was the sense of unity and church and commonality that touched me in this blog…. THANK YOU

  2. George Henke says:

    It should be noted that Bill Wilson’s wife, in her book, “Irene Remembers”, tells how Bill “poured over”, read constantly Science and Health, the Christian Science textbook, to lift himself out of “drinking”.

    Bill Wilson was in Canton, Ohio and supposedly knew and was in touch with a Christian Science Practitioner in Canton during those times.

  3. dean says:

    What a story that AA is and now to find a connection to C.S.? Eddy could have written 24 hrs a day. More research. I wonder if I could do my 4,5 steps with a practioner? I practised CS as a young adult but drifted to sin. Alcohol brought me back I hope for good. Success bred my ego such a temptation.

  4. It is sad the people often interpret the statement “I am an alcoholic and am powerless over alcohol “out of context as a dis-empowering speech. (See feature article). Those who haveexperienced making this sincerely speech act experience it as a tremendously empowering moment in the process of recovery. It is an act of telling the real and experiential truth that has been denied and buried under a mountain of shame, in most cases for years and even decades. It is the lie that dis-empowers. That is why making it a public act in the context of an AA meeting is such an important part of the ritual of transformation, It does not represent a commitment to go forward in the slavery of that lie, that would indeed be folly. It represents a commitment to tell the truth. Finally telling the denied truth creates a condition in which we can indeed be free, Up until the moment of its saying the alcoholic is powerless. Repeating this act at meetings ritually reminds the speaker that that her or his freedom and empowerment began with with telling the truth.That is how it was and will be if we forget it.

  5. Pingback: A.A. and Christian Science – Overcoming Addiction Part II – Daily Bread – 02/04/2014 « Emergence International

  6. Withheld says:

    I find this article timeless and universal. The following comment was sent in to a discussion we were having and seems appropriate to post on your comments.

    I was finding healing in the writings and teachings of Mary Baker Eddy. But it was AA that provided me with an authentic feeling of connection or fellowship with others that I could not find at my branch church. The fellowship from AA was meeting the human need for the connection so many of us yearn for without all the judgement.

    Name Withheld

  7. Bev Newsham says:

    I, too, have to sing the praises of 12-Step Groups! I was raised in C.S., but had an abusive experience in the home and suppressed the memories as long as I could. One day, after combatting depression for years, I thought I’d give C.S. one last chance and desperately began studying it – grasping at straws. Then the memories came up and I was clearly lead to stop studying C.S. and to attend Co-Dependents Anonymous 12-step Group, which I did. I experienced so much love, honesty and closeness to my Higher Power and to the Group! I am trying to come back into C.S. – but I always keep one foot in the 12-Steps!

  8. Pingback: Can we keep a “conscious contact with God”? – 07/21/2014 « Emergence International

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s